Infant Car Seat Vs. Convertible Car Seat: Which One Is Safer 

One of the biggest hurdles a parent can go through is choosing whether or not they need an infant car seat or a convertible one.  If you’re not sure which one you should get between infant car seat vs. convertible car seat, then look no further. Here, we’ll talk about which one is safer, and while there isn’t a clear winner, you should figure out which one best fits your needs, and why both of them are important for newborns. 


Do You Want It To Grow With The Kid? 

It is probably the biggest question you will want to ask. While the seats are both incredibly safe, one of them is much more limited. Convertible car seats go from an infant style to where it is facing the back of the seat, to front-facing, to finally a booster seat, and in many cases can hold up to 120-130 pounds. That is a long time! And if you’re a parent that is more on a budget, this might be a better option. 

Infant car seats tend to protect a child when they are an infant. This period is a formative time in their life, and you might want to consider this, especially if you’re looking to protect the kid in every single way adequately and to make sure that they are inside. This seat protects the head a lot more, too, since that is usually where a lot of the trauma in children during accidents lie. 


Alternating Cars 

If you’re a parent that is alternating cars, or perhaps one parent drops up, and one of them picks them up, you might want to consider an infant car seat. Infant car seats are great for this since this is actually super easy to get the seat out and then snapped into the other one. So, if you’re switching cars a lot, this is a better option.

But, if you’re a person that is only using one car for most things, you can get away with a convertible car seat, but remember that these types of car seats are much harder to alternate between since they aren’t to be taken out of the car.  Infant car seats are also great cause they can be converted into baby carriers as well, and parents can take this out to leave, which is fantastic if you’re worried about disturbing their sleep. 

If you want to let your child sleep whenever you take them out of the car, consider the infant car seat, and usually, infant car seats are compatible with strollers too. What that means is that if you get one of those travel packs, you can literally pull the seat out, and then put it in there, and it is super easy. 

Growth Spurt Considerations 

It is another big part of whether or not one is better than the other. If you notice that your child is growing incredibly fast, you might want to consider a convertible car seat. Rear-facing seats are suitable for the first year, and usually, this is good for some children, but convertible car seats also offer extended rear-facing when it comes to weight and height limits. As they grow up, you can switch to convertible car seats that are front-facing, and it’s super easy to change this.  You can continue to use that for a bit, and you can, with convertible seats, convert them as needed.

Unfortunately, with infant sets, if your child grows fast, you’ll need to get a forward-facing one, and finally a booster seat, which is a drawback. And if they grow too fast, you might not be ready, which can put their lives in danger. 

Stroller Considerations 

Again, if you’re a parent that likes to use those stroller travel packs, then you should get an infant car seat since they’re often bundled. They also are cheaper if you go that way. If you think you’re going to be using a stroller a lot, you should consider this option. But, if you’re okay with purchasing separate strollers, then you can get a convertible seat. 


It also can save you time, since it’s much easier just to pull it out, put the stroller down, and then throw them into the stroller.  You don’t have to wake up the kid either. 

Which One Is Safer Though? 

Here’s the thing, both of these are incredibly safe. Infant ones are to protect the kid during those years, and convertible ones grow with the kid.

The way to make these unsafe is, of course, if you decide to misuse them. That’s probably the one way you can make these dangerous, and you’d be surprised at how many parents set these up wrong. If you get these, you should always make sure that you follow the instructions.

Infant car seats require a whole lot less time to set up than the convertible ones, and convertible ones stay in the car, so remember that. 

TSA Safe? 

Some car seats are safe for TSA.  Convertible ones are safe for kids for the most part, and they can be taken on the plane.  You will need to gate check these, and you will want to make sure that you know how to set these up properly. But, the benefit of the convertible is that you can pull it out and take it with you, but the downside is you need to take it out of the car. 


Whatever one you choose, infant car seat vs. convertible car seat, remember that there are pros and cons to each, and you should figure out whether or not you want to save money on the stroller for the infant, or if you want to save money in the long term. Regardless, this should be something that you should make sure that you buy immediately, and something you should have on hand for your child whenever possible since it helps to keep them safe and sound while they’re in the car, and protects their bodies. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

DISCLAIMER (IMPORTANT): This information (including all text, images, audio, or other formats on is not intended to be a substitute for informed professional advice, diagnosis, endorsement or treatment. You should not take any action or avoid taking action without consulting a qualified professional.   Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions about medical conditions. Do not disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking advice or treatment because of something you have read here a

Last Updated on:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.